Raining Cats and Dogs, Ropes, and Old Women With Clubs

An idiom is a phrase whose meaning cannot be worked out from its words. English speakers say it is raining cats and dogs without picturing any animals. Every language has thousands of these, and comparing them across languages is one of the more entertaining things you can do with a dictionary.

Heavy rain

LanguageIdiomLiterally
Englishraining cats and dogs—
Frenchil pleut des cordesit's raining ropes
Spanishllueve a cántarosit's raining pitchers
Germanes regnet Bindfädenit's raining string
Dutchhet regent pijpenstelenit's raining pipe stems
Portuguesechove a cântarosit's raining jugs
Greekβρέχει καρεκλοπόδαραit's raining chair legs
Welshbwrw hen wragedd a ffynraining old women and sticks

Several languages converge on long thin objects falling — ropes, string, pipe stems, chair legs — which is a reasonable description of heavy rain. English and Welsh went somewhere else entirely.

Something that will never happen

LanguageIdiomLiterally
Englishwhen pigs fly—
Frenchquand les poules auront des dentswhen hens have teeth
Russianкогда рак на горе свистнетwhen the crayfish whistles on the mountain
Dutchals Pasen en Pinksteren op één dag vallenwhen Easter and Pentecost fall on the same day
Italianquando gli asini volerannowhen donkeys fly
Finnishkun lehmät lentävätwhen cows fly
Romanianla paștele cailorat the horses' Easter

Impossibility idioms cluster around two images: animals doing what they cannot, and calendar events that cannot coincide. The Russian crayfish is the outlier, and it is specific enough that it survives as a recognisable cultural reference rather than as a generic phrase.

Not being quite right in the head

LanguageIdiomLiterally
Englisha few sandwiches short of a picnic—
Germannicht alle Tassen im Schrank habennot have all the cups in the cupboard
Dutchvan het padje af zijnto be off the little path
Swedishha en skruv lösto have a screw loose
Polishmieć nierówno pod sufitemto have it uneven under the ceiling
Spanishfaltarle un tornilloto be missing a screw

The mechanical image — a loose or missing screw — recurs across several unrelated languages, and is recent enough that it must postdate widespread machinery.

It's not my problem

LanguageIdiomLiterally
Englishnot my circus, not my monkeysborrowed from Polish
Polishnie mój cyrk, nie moje małpynot my circus, not my monkeys
Germannicht mein Biernot my beer
Frenchce n'est pas mes oignonsthose aren't my onions
Japanese対岸の火事a fire on the opposite bank

The English version is a recent direct borrowing from Polish, which is a reminder that idiom inventories are not closed — they gain entries when a phrase is vivid enough to travel.

Why translation fails on them

Idioms are stored as whole units. Their meaning is not composed from their parts, so any process working part by part produces nonsense. This is why machine translation, which has become very good at ordinary sentences, still produces conspicuous errors on idiomatic ones — and why a literal rendering is often a reliable signal that a phrase was idiomatic.

The corresponding advice for learners is to store them whole too. Learn il pleut des cordes as a single item meaning heavy rain, without dissecting it, exactly as you learned raining cats and dogs without asking questions.

Recognise early, use late

Comprehension is the priority: idioms are frequent in ordinary speech and missing one derails a sentence. Production is riskier, because register and currency are difficult to judge from outside — some idioms are dated, some regional, some faintly ridiculous in the mouth of a learner.

A reasonable rule is to use an idiom only after hearing it used naturally by someone whose register you would be comfortable borrowing. Until then, plain phrasing is always available and never sounds wrong.

Check the words inside the idiom

Idioms are learned whole, but the words still need looking up. NDT Studio's free offline dictionaries cover 45 language pairs.

Open the dictionary app

Frequently asked questions

Why can't idioms be translated literally?

Because their meaning is not built from their parts. Kick the bucket means to die, and nothing about kicking or buckets gets you there. Translating word by word produces a phrase that is grammatical and meaningless, which is why machine translation still stumbles on them.

Do different languages share any idioms?

Many, through borrowing or shared cultural sources. Biblical and classical phrases recur across Europe, and modern English idioms spread widely through media. Independent coincidence also happens where the underlying image is obvious enough.

How should learners approach idioms?

Learn to recognise them long before trying to use them. Comprehension is what you need, since idioms are frequent in speech; production is risky because register and currency are hard to judge, and a misjudged idiom is more conspicuous than plain phrasing.